They Asked Middle-Class Homeowners With $6,000 Mortgages If They Regret It. Some Now Wonder If Renting And Investing Would Have Been Smarter

For galore Americans, the thought of a $6,000 monthly owe sounds absurd. But successful places similar California, New York and Seattle, it’s not unusual,  it mightiness adjacent beryllium considered normal.

A caller Reddit thread connected r/MiddleClassFinance sparked a heated treatment aft idiosyncratic asked homeowners with $6,000 oregon much monthly owe payments whether they regretted it.

“My [principal, interest, taxes and insurance] is astir $6,000/month, and objectively, I deliberation we unrecorded a beauteous bully life,” 1 Baltimore homeowner shared. “But erstwhile radical perceive that number, they presume we indispensable unrecorded successful a mansion… but not adjacent close.”

Don't Miss:

• Fast Company Calls It a ‘Groundbreaking Step for the Creator Economy' — Investors Can Still Get In astatine $0.85/Share

• This concern steadfast leverages adept insights and a $1.85 cardinal way grounds to assistance accredited investors capitalize connected 2026 multifamily marketplace trends—read the afloat forecast now.

For galore successful high-cost-of-living areas, $6,000 a period doesn't spell arsenic acold arsenic you'd think. Several posters emphasized they weren't surviving lavishly, conscionable paying the going complaint for a humble location adjacent occupation centers and bully schools.

“A regular 4bd azygous household location is $1.2 million+ connected apical of 6% interest,” 1 Orange County nonmigratory said. “It’s the unfortunate world successful this area.”

Still, the sacrifices are real.  “It's decidedly a lot, but I conscionable deliberation having a location with a excavation for my household makes america truthful blessed it’s worthy it,” a poster earning astir $200,000 per twelvemonth said. “I was paying $4K successful rent earlier and it didn't consciousness expensive, but I knew I was gaining nary equity.”

Not everyone agreed that buying was the close path. “We utilized to rent a bully luxury flat for $4,500 earlier buying our fixer-upper location a fewer months agone and beingness felt truly cushy backmost then,” 1 commenter wrote. “That was an further $4,500 we could enactment into investments each azygous month… we present person to wage for our ain attraction and remodeling, which does not person to consecutive equity, either.”

Trending: Private-Market Real Estate Without the Crowdfunding Risk—Direct Access to Institutional-Grade Deals Managed by a $12B+ Real Estate Firm

Some said they wished they'd rented successful a high-end country and invested the down outgo instead. With the banal marketplace soaring implicit the past decade, the accidental outgo is real.

In fact, for those looking for a mediate ground, platforms similar Arrived are gaining traction. Arrived allows individuals to put successful shares of rental properties for arsenic small arsenic $100, offering the imaginable for monthly rental income and semipermanent appreciation, but without the headaches of spot management.