Book Review
When It All Burns: Fighting Fire successful a Transformed World
By Jordan Thomas
Riverhead Books: 368 pages, $30
If you bargain books linked connected our site, The Times whitethorn gain a committee from Bookshop.org, whose fees enactment autarkic bookstores.
Jordan Thomas didn’t privation to conscionable probe and constitute astir fire, helium wanted to spot it up close, and helium has turned that acquisition into the exceptional caller book, “When It All Burns.” A specializer successful the taste forces that signifier fire, Thomas joined the Los Padres Hotshots, a unit that mightiness beryllium viewed arsenic the Navy SEALs of firefighting. He spent 2021 battling wildfires utmost and treacherous adjacent by the standards of these globally warmed times.
A first-person relationship would beryllium compelling enough, particularly fixed Thomas’ acquisition for terse, layered expository writing. But Thomas has much connected his caput here. He alternates sequences of harrowing enactment and macho team-building with heavy dives into the ecology, science, economics and, astir important, Indigenous taste practices related to fire. In Thomas’ hands these subjects are interconnected, and his penning brings caller vigor to an ubiquitous subject.

(Riverhead Books)
If you unrecorded anyplace adjacent Los Angeles, you whitethorn precise good similar not to work “When It All Burns.” But you should. Just this past January, a bid of wildfires ravaged the region, fed by gusting Santa Ana winds, drought conditions and debased humidity. Projected harm from the fires had ballooned to much than $250 cardinal successful damages successful January, The Times reported. At slightest 30 radical were killed successful the fires, with economical ramifications expected to agelong into the unforeseeable future. “When It All Burns” was written good earlier immoderate of this happened, and it sometimes carries the unit of prophecy. The occurrence adjacent clip has already burned, though determination volition surely beryllium more.
Thomas sets the array aboriginal on: “In the past 2 decades, wildfires person been doing things not adjacent machine models tin predict, biology events that person scientists racking their brains for appropriately Dystopian technology: firenados, gigafires, megafires. Scientists precocious invented the word ‘megafire’ to picture wildfires that behave successful ways that would person been intolerable conscionable a procreation ago, burning done winter, exploding successful the night, and devastating landscapes historically impervious to incendiary destruction.”
In different words, it’s lone going to get worse. As a subordinate of the Hotshots crew, Thomas hacked distant astatine undergrowth with a chainsaw arsenic the firefighters made their advance, and helium recovered himself fascinated by the subculture of people, mostly men, assigned to combat these otherworldly infernos. But the acquisition and cognition helium carries besides makes him profoundly ambivalent astir the precise quality of occurrence suppression.

Author Jordan Thomas.
(Sari Blum)
For centuries, Indigenous peoples the satellite implicit person utilized controlled fires, oregon “cultural burning,” for immoderate fig of purposes, from agriculture to reducing the hazard of uncontrolled fires. But specified practices didn’t jibe with progressively modern economies, and colonialists, particularly successful North America, saw burning arsenic some barbaric and a menace to industrialized capitalism. Fire surpression was much than a byproduct of Native American genocide, it was portion of the maestro plan: “In California, occurrence had ever connected radical to their food, and Americans acceptable astir its suppression with unprecedented brutality.” Researchers who tried to bring this past to airy often had their enactment suppressed similar 1 much controlled fire. And arsenic the signifier declined, wildfires entered the breach.
As you mightiness expect, beingness arsenic a Hotshot is fraught with aesculapian risk: Hotshots thin to enactment sick and injured, loathe to walk up the overtime and hazard wage connected which they depend. As Thomas writes, “The precarious lives of Hotshots are 1 flashpoint successful an expanding tract of self-reinforcing societal and biology crises. Scientists telephone this a sacrifice portion — a spot wherever low-income radical enarthrosis the load of concern misconduct.”
Every clip “When It All Burns” threatens to get dry, similar a combustible portion of brush, Thomas brings it backmost to his ain firefighting travails, and the formed of Hotshot characters who showed him the ropes, berated him and bailed him out.
The 2 Los Padres leaders are Edgar, a stern drill sergeant-type who rides everyone with adjacent venom, and Aoki, conscionable arsenic demanding but with much of a shaman-warrior demeanor. Aoki conducts Thomas’ occupation interrogation arsenic the 2 men hike a steep hill; Thomas yet has to determine betwixt asking questions, which takes up oxygen, oregon concentrating connected the task astatine hand.
“At a definite level of carnal suffering, the symptom becomes astir comedic,” helium notes, arsenic helium assesses his information earlier hiking a upland to transportation an injured firefighter backmost downhill. “My feet were torn and oozing wrong my elk leather boots, and each inch of my tegument was a rash of poison oak. Hours earlier I had been incapacitated by musculus cramps.” And moments later: “The lone antidote to the discomfort was to instrumentality to the level of exhaustion wherever the assemblage becomes numb.”
“When It All Burns” is 1 of those books that immerses the scholar successful the nuances of a satellite astir of america cognize lone done the lens of calamity and destruction. Thomas’ visceral, crystalline prose lone adds substance to the fire.
Vognar is simply a freelance civilization writer.