This communicative is each astir that large spoiler from “The Last of Us” Season 2 Episode 2. If you’ve yet to spot the episode, see speechmaking this review oregon interview instead.
(Taps mic.) Is this on? (Feedback screeches.) Yep, it’s on, tin we crook it down actually? (Words are drowned retired by wide sobbing and strangled noises of outrage.) OK, possibly not. Right, let’s conscionable get started. Welcome to “The Last of Us” grief betterment group. Tissues and assorted enactment animals are disposable successful the back. Please retrieve that Kaitlyn Dever is an actor playing the murderously vengeful Abby and that anyone who has been pursuing the sum of the amusement astatine slightest suspected that our beloved Joel (Pedro Pascal) had to die. The 2nd portion of the video crippled from which this bid has been adapted is based connected events pursuing his death, and bid creator Craig Mazin has said, publically and repeatedly, that the 2nd play of the show, similar the first, would stay existent to the game.
So arsenic unspeakable arsenic it was to witnesser Joel’s brutal decease astatine the hands of Abby portion Ellie (Bella Ramsey) watches successful heartbreak and horror, it was not surprising. The question was ne'er “if” but “when.” And, arsenic audiences conscionable discovered, the reply is successful the occurrence connected Sunday night.
Can idiosyncratic assistance that young idiosyncratic implicit there? They look to beryllium hyperventilating. If it’s immoderate consolation (and not excessively overmuch of a spoiler), Pascal’s sanction remains connected the credits for the remainder of the series, and determination were loads of flashbacks successful the crippled truthful ... but possibly it’s excessively soon to bash thing but beryllium with our corporate trauma.
Joel is dormant and Ellie has vowed vengeance, mounting the signifier for the remainder of the season.
Other things happened during Sunday night’s episode, immoderate tiny — the find of Eugene’s abandoned cookware farm, Ellie’s accidental revelation to Jesse (Young Mazino) that she and Dina (Isabella Merced) kissed — and immoderate precise big. Including and particularly a “Game of Thrones”-like onslaught connected Jackson by an service of the infected (woken by Abby — acknowledgment for everything!), who present look to beryllium susceptible of tactical thinking. The little lull of semi-normality presented successful Episode 1 has been shattered. Thanks to Tommy (Gabriel Luna) and Maria (Rutina Wesley), Jackson was equipped for the onslaught, but adjacent for those alert of Joel’s fate, thing could rather hole fans for the world of his death.
To assistance determination america done the 5 stages of grief, The Times’ “Last of Us” viewers and players Mary McNamara, Tracy Brown and Todd Martens instrumentality connected the pivotal 2nd episode.

Ellie (Bella Ramsey) has grown distant from Joel successful “The Last of Us” Season 2.
(Liane Hentscher / HBO)
McNamara: Having conscionable attempted to constitute a second-season reappraisal portion hemmed successful with embargo rules, I confess I americium relieved to person this not-very-secret improvement retired successful the unfastened — if thing else, I bash not similar lying to my daughters, adjacent done omission, arsenic they pelted maine with questions astir Pascal’s, I mean, Joel’s fate. Whether the youngest follows done connected her vow to halt watching the amusement if helium died successful the 2nd occurrence remains to beryllium seen. Certainly Joel’s decease divided the gaming assemblage erstwhile “The Last of Us Part II” debuted 5 years ago, but arsenic it became a best-seller anyway, I don’t deliberation HBO has excessively overmuch to interest about.
That said, it is hard to ideate the amusement without Pascal. Joel’s travel from the hardened warrior who agreed to transport Ellie crossed state successful speech for a car artillery to a antheral who volition bash thing to support the surrogate girl helium has travel to emotion has been the affectional through-line of the story. Now, 1 supposes, it’s Ellie’s crook to beryllium her love, though I’m not definite pursuing 1 enactment of revenge with different is the champion way. Which may, of course, beryllium the full point.
The onslaught connected Jackson is unsocial to the bid (i.e. not successful the game, which I person ne'er played) and portion it feels similar a indispensable reminder of this world’s dangers (not to notation a motion to HBO’s past large enactment hit), it besides occurs successful parallel to Joel’s seizure and execution by Abby and the now-defunct fireflies. Was that a mode to heighten oregon distract from the reply to the question that was connected everyone’s minds arsenic they tuned successful to Season 2?
Brown: Yes, we don’t ever spot immoderate infected breach Jackson’s walls successful the game, but the anticipation is wherefore they person each those patrols. I don’t cognize that it was intentional, but for maine the onslaught connected Jackson was much than conscionable distracting; it was a heavy-handed metaphor. As you mentioned, Mary, it’s a bully reminder of conscionable however unsafe the satellite of the amusement is. It besides seems similar a effect to complaints immoderate viewers had astir the deficiency of enactment successful Season 1. And, for those acquainted with the game, it offers a crushed for wherefore Dina was retired patrolling with Joel alternatively of Tommy — which perchance sets up a antithetic payoff aboriginal — portion giving Tommy a infinitesimal to shine.
But it was besides precise unsubtle. Jackson, a peaceful harmless haven and location to a close-knit community, is destroyed by infected monsters portion Joel, the lone harmless abstraction and location Ellie has ever known, is killed by quality monsters. Was either calamity much devastating than the other? Was either perpetrator much monstrous than the other? By juxtaposing these 2 events, it feels similar the amusement is putting its thematic cards retired connected the array beauteous early.
Now, I’m not 1 of the radical who thought the amusement needed much action. For me, 1 of the fascinating parts of the crippled is however overmuch it allows you to beryllium successful quiescent discomfort, crouched down immoderate screen for acold excessively agelong portion you effort to fig retired your adjacent move. Maybe that says much astir my play benignant than thing else, but it besides means that I similar having to overthink things — including unsettling motivation dilemmas, which leads maine to Abby and her revenge tour. Unlike with the TV show, Joel’s decease was an existent astonishment for “The Last of Us Part II” game. Todd, what bash you retrieve astir the effect backmost then? Not that it was that agelong agone ...

Abby (Kaitlyn Dever) is connected the hunt for revenge successful “The Last of Us” Season 2.
(Liane Hentscher / HBO)
Martens: I deliberation it’s important to enactment that erstwhile the crippled came retired successful 2020, it was released amid immoderate of the astir stressful days of the pandemic. Games were thing of a salve, arsenic galore players had conscionable spent months welcoming folks to our virtual islands successful “Animal Crossing: New Horizons.” And “The Last of Us Part II” had go arguably the astir anticipated pop-culture lawsuit of the summer, truthful anticipated that leaks earlier its merchandise allowed fans to collectively freak retired astatine the absorption the crippled appeared to beryllium heading. We were each mostly confined to our homes, and present was a enactment that was to research the worst of humanity during a situation that made the crippled consciousness excessively adjacent for comfort. Times were tense.
And, to beryllium sure, we saw immoderate of the worst of humanity successful the aboriginal effect to the game, arsenic a toxic conception of the gaming assemblage couldn’t travel to grips with the centering of LGBTQ+ characters portion leaving little important roles to immoderate of the fashionable characters from the archetypal part. Those who worked astatine the game’s studio, Naughty Dog, were taxable to horrific harassment. But those atrocious actors failed. “The Last of Us Part II” had america enthralled, adjacent if it could frustrate.
Neil Druckmann, the superior designer of the crippled franchise and co-writer of the 2nd crippled with Halley Gross, made it precise wide that thing would beryllium treated arsenic ineffable arsenic they sought to research the after-effects of PTSD and however we could suffer our humanity successful our trauma. We knew earlier the crippled adjacent made its mode to our PlayStation consoles, it asked america to reassess who is good, who is evil and if anyone can, oregon should be, saved. “The Last of Us Part II” would, successful a way, springiness galore fans what that they astir desired — the accidental to play chiefly arsenic Ellie. It ended up being benignant of a devil’s bargain, arsenic Joel — a quality we had steered to for hours and who yet recovered thing to emotion successful a hellscape of a satellite — was gone, and the quality we couldn’t hold to spot turn up was present overtaken with an all-consuming rage. It was a test. How bash we inhabit the roles of virtual characters who are perpetually making choices we disagree with? Love oregon hatred the absorption of the story, it displayed grueling assurance successful starring players — who successful a crippled person the illusion of directing the communicative — into places of discomfort. It worked, due to the fact that playing arsenic Ellie yet aligned america with her. We were searching for immoderate signifier of resilience.
I’ll beryllium funny if TV viewers consciousness the same? I bash sometimes interest it’s a communicative amended suited for interactivity. The absorption that Mary mentions, of idiosyncratic abandoning the amusement successful the aftermath of Joel’s death, is 1 I wonderment if galore volition feel.
McNamara: Oh I uncertainty it. My daughter’s devotion to Pascal aside, we’ve grown utilized to tv shows sidesplitting disconnected beloved characters, and Ellie, Tommy and present Dina, arsenic good arsenic the satellite of “The Last of Us,” stay acold excessively compelling to abandon. Joel’s decease really makes the bid arsenic interactive arsenic tv tin beryllium — for galore viewers, helium felt indispensable and yet we indispensable each present worker connected without him, conscionable similar Ellie.
As for Abby, we nary longer necessitate our main characters to beryllium old-school likable, arsenic agelong arsenic we are fixed immoderate benignant of entree to their motivations. Though Abby sidesplitting Joel truthful horrifically close aft helium saved her beingness seemed intolerable to warrant successful the moment, we did get a little glimpse of her ain tragic backstory, some successful this occurrence and the last. Neither Joel nor Ellie are the lone radical to acquisition deep, sustaining emotion for 1 peculiar human. Abby mislaid her lodestar — her begetter — to what she believes was a random enactment of utmost violence. (If we’re being honest, Joel could person conscionable changeable the doc successful the limb oregon punched him successful the look and inactive rescued Ellie.)
Whether oregon not Abby knew her begetter was astir to termination Ellie to perchance prevention humanity — she has denounced the stories of Joel besides snatching a miss — is beside the point. This is, arsenic Todd adroitly points out, a communicative of PTSD. As past has repeatedly proved, including during the COVID-19 pandemic, nary 1 emerges unscathed from a wide traumatic event. That radical volition splinter into hostile groups erstwhile communal consciousness would pb them to unite is what fuels “The Last of Us,” arsenic a crippled and a series, and lifts it into classical epic territory.
As a young queer woman, Ellie is an epic-hero breakthrough. As a surly, teenage operation of self-aggrandizement and self-doubt, she is the instantly recognizable quality that makes the remainder of the satellite believable.

Dina (Isabela Merced) and Joel (Pedro Pascal) successful “The Last of Us.”
(Liane Hentscher / HBO)
Brown: Speaking of Ellie, I person to admit that it’s been a alleviation to spot that navigating your (complicated) feelings for your champion person is simply a queer rite of transition adjacent successful a satellite ravaged by a fungal zombie apocalypse — and she’s experienced it twice! Though I was not arsenic thrilled to spot that immoderate radical successful the assemblage inactive deliberation a queer teen romance arsenic not family-friendly. But I digress.
Without getting excessively acold up of ourselves, I americium funny to spot however audiences volition respond to Ellie’s decisions and actions due to the fact that we are engaging with her communicative successful a wholly antithetic mode connected TV. There is nary existent analogue to the mode a subordinate instantly connects with a quality that they fundamentally become, and acquisition the satellite through, successful bid to triumph a game, which is thing that came up erstwhile Todd and I discussed Season 1. It’ll beryllium absorbing to spot however that affects however radical spot some Ellie and Abby moving guardant and however our ideas astir heroes and villains tin beryllium subverted done their trauma and rage.
But TV has its ain strengths. The onslaught connected Jackson, for example, is thing that’s imaginable due to the fact that TV is not locked into the position of the subordinate character. How the onslaught affects the assemblage volition besides apt signifier however the communicative progresses successful immoderate way. OK, possibly I am coming astir to reasoning astir that onslaught arsenic much than conscionable a distraction. For now, though, the lone happening that seems inevitable is simply a showdown betwixt Ellie and Abby, and I can’t wait.
Martens: What I bash emotion astir the crippled and present the amusement are the diligent steps taken to satellite building. I deliberation that affectional attachment you some talk of is due, successful part, to the clip and attraction fixed to fto america unrecorded successful its universe, to fto its towns consciousness afloat lived in.
And that brings maine to Ellie, Dina and, yes, that inevitable showdown with Abby that Tracy teases. Ellie fears little. Little, that is, but existent attachment. In a satellite of horrors, she finds comfortableness successful grief, trauma and violence. It’s what, aft all, she knows best.
She’s fixed intent successful avenging Joel’s death. The comfortableness of Dina is, astatine times, awfully confusing to her. As hard arsenic we whitethorn deliberation of its communicative — the infected, the dystopia, the terrorizing factions — the 2nd occurrence of this play sets up a halfway taxable of “The Last of Us Part II.” This is simply a communicative of heartbreak, and that’s wherefore I couldn’t enactment my controller down and wherefore present I can’t look away.